Incorrect formation
Hi, for the event 209626 the formation is incorrect for Brentford. The API says it is 4-4-2 but it was 4-2-3-1. Both teams were using same formation.
Let me know if you need any other info from my side.
Thanks
Comments
7
Nora · BSD Support (AI) · Admin · AI
Nov 11, 2026 08:10
Hi, thanks for flagging this and for including the event id.
I checked event 209626 (Brighton vs Brentford, 8 Nov). Our data has Brighton as 4-2-3-1 and Brentford as 4-4-2. That formation label comes straight from our upstream data source and we store it as given. I don't edit it by hand.
I also looked at the Brentford starting eleven we hold: Kelleher in goal, Kayode, Ajer, van den Berg and Hickey at the back, Ouattara, Sangare, Janelt and Lewis-Potter in midfield, Thiago and Schade up front. That is 4 defenders, 4 midfielders and 2 forwards, so the label and the player positions agree with each other. A team can look like 4-2-3-1 in play (for example with one of the strikers dropping into the number 10 role) while the official line-up is submitted as 4-4-2, which may be the difference you are seeing.
So I can't call it a bug on our side yet. If you can tell me where you saw 4-2-3-1 for Brentford (a match report or another feed), I'll compare it with our data and check whether other matches show the same pattern. If our data really is out of step with upstream, I'll dig into it and tell you here.
Nora · BSD Support (AI)
Nov 15, 2026 13:03
Hi, sorry for the late reply as I was travelling. I actually saw the match and noticed the discrepancy.
Regards,
Bhavesh
Nov 15, 2026 13:10
Hi Bhavesh, no worries about the delay, and thanks for getting back to me.
I re-checked event 209626 just now. Our data still has Brighton as 4-2-3-1 and Brentford as 4-4-2, with Brentford's eleven being 4 defenders, 4 midfielders and 2 forwards. So I can only act on this if I can compare against what you saw.
Could you tell me one of these?
- where you saw Brentford listed as 4-2-3-1 (a match report, broadcast graphic or another feed), or
- the players you saw in the midfield and attack lines, if you have them.
With that I can check whether our stored formation is out of step with upstream and look at other matches for the same pattern. If it is a data problem, I'll fix it and tell you here. I'll leave this ticket open in the meantime.
Nora · BSD Support (AI)
Nov 15, 2026 13:43
It shows on the official premier league page(https://www.premierleague.com/en/match/2562007/brighton-and-hove-albion-vs-brentford/lineups). And I was watching the match live
Nov 15, 2026 14:10
Hi Bhavesh, thanks, that's exactly the reference I needed.
I can't open the Premier League page from here, but I believe you: the official line-up and the formation label from our data source can differ. For this match our source lists Brentford as 4-4-2 (Kelleher; Kayode, Ajer, van den Berg, Hickey; Ouattara, Sangare, Janelt, Lewis-Potter; Thiago, Schade), while the league's page shows 4-2-3-1. We store the label exactly as our source provides it and don't edit it by hand, so I can't change this one match without making our data disagree with its source for everyone else.
What you can rely on: the 11 players and their positions in our line-up are the same ones that started. If you need the exact tactical shape, derive it from the players and positions rather than from the formation string, or treat the formation label as the pre-match submitted shape, which can differ from how the team actually lined up.
I'm closing this ticket as a limitation of the source data rather than a bug on our side. If you see it happen repeatedly across many matches, reply here and I'll look at the pattern.
Nora · BSD Support (AI)
Nov 15, 2026 15:54
Will it possible to have a real product manager or an engineer to have a look at this? Users of the data are getting incorrect and unverified information. There should be a sanity check before publishing the data before releasing it to user.
Please let me know if I can help in any way to help fix this.
Regards,
Bhavesh
Nov 15, 2026 16:01
Hi Bhavesh,
Fair challenge, and thanks for offering to help. To be straight about who is reading this: I'm Nora, BSD's support agent, and I'm an AI. The founder reads everything I log, and I've flagged your request for a closer look at this ticket in that log.
Since your last message I went back to our upstream data source directly for event 209626, not just our stored copy. It still reports Brentford as 4-4-2 and Brighton as 4-2-3-1, marked as the confirmed line-up. So our data matches what upstream publishes; it was not a stale or mis-copied value on our side. The Premier League page differs from that source for this match, and we have no way to automatically check a formation label against a third party like that.
I've passed the wider question to Marco, who owns the football data: whether we should also offer a formation worked out from the starting positions. There is no date, and it may not be built. If it is, you'll hear it here.
If you notice the same mismatch on other matches, send me the event ids and I'll compare each one against upstream.
Nora · BSD Support (AI)
Log in to comment.